Historical Record of Pastoral Service
Methodist Episcopal Ministers That Held Services
In Lake City Before This Church Organized
| 1874 | John Robinson | 1881 | A.W. Noyes |
| 1878-1880 | J.M. Whitney | 1881-1882 | Anthony Duddles |
| 1880 | - Spencer | 1881-1883 | H.L. Dorrance |
Ministers That Have Served This Church
| 1883-1884 | Irving Eagle | 1928-1933 | D.L. Reedy |
| 1884-1887 | J.M. Smith | 1933-1934 | J.H. Rayle |
| 1887-1888 | E.A. Turner | 1934-1937 | J.M. DeVinney |
| 1888-1889 | J.W. Steffe | 1937 | Harold E. Dixon |
| 1889-1891 | G.W. Howe | 1938-1940 | Willis Hunting |
| 1891-1894 | James Berry | 1940-1943 | Donn Doten |
| 1894-1895 | W.D. Rowland | 1943-1948 | Rollie Poe |
| 1895-1896 | A. Newton | 1948-1956 | Cecil H. Scott |
| 1896-1898 | George Varion | 1956-1957 | John Alexander |
| 1898-1901 | John C. Beach | 1958-1959 | Lee Smith |
| 1901-1903 | H.J. Freeman | 1959-1962 | George Pardee |
| 1903-1906 | John Bretts | 1962 | Wm. R. Catton |
| 1906-1909 | A.E. Wynn | 1962-1965 | Wirth Tennant |
| 1909-1910 | R.E. Yost | 1965-1970 | J. Wm Schoettle |
| 1910-1914 | C.S. Jenkins | 1970-1972 | Leonard Yarlott |
| 1914-1917 | M.E. Hoyt | 1972-1976 | Ward Pierce |
| 1917-1919 | A.J. Preston | 1976-1979 | Ross Bunce |
| 1919-1922 | W.W. Lamport | 1979-1985 | Willard Gilroy |
| 1922-1923 | L.K. Long | 1985-1996 | David L Dryer |
| 1924 | B. Swem | 1996-2000 | Jane Crabtree |
| 1924-1925 | W.W. Lamport | 2000-2010 | Edrye Maurer |
| 1925-1928 | L.H. Wheeler | 2010-2019 | Jean Smith |
| 2019-2023 | Russell K. Logston | ||
| 2023 - Present | James Noggle |